Taking Dialogue to the Next Level, By Joshua Stanton

Posted on May 2nd, 2009 | Filed under Best Practices/Non-Profit, Faith and Politics, On Campus

In recent years, peacebuilders have recognised the need for interfaith discussion. It is no longer difficult to find a medium for dialogue. Churches, mosques, temples and synagogues, as well as a myriad of non-profit organisations, offer programmes centred on dialogue between members of different religious traditions. Yet many of these well-intentioned initiatives succumb to an unproductive default: we are all really just the same.


Fundamentally rooted in politeness, such notions overlook the differences that do exist between religious traditions and inhibit conversation about the topics that actually cause friction between communities. The real challenge in interfaith dialogue is finding a way to effectively engage difficult topics. Doing so holds the potential to bring a deeper level of understanding between religious communities and a significant reduction in tension.


Recently, I had the chance to meet with Muslim and Jewish high school students participating in the Face to Face programme, sponsored by the Interreligious Coordinating Council in Israel (ICCI). The group is said to be the only inter-religious programme for youth in Israel that continued to meet regularly even after the outbreak of the recent conflict in Gaza.


Their strategy for success was not to avoid feelings of anger and grief in the course of meetings, but to guide the expression of these sentiments.


Some Muslim students in the group had relatives living in Gaza who were directly impacted by the war. Some of the Jewish students worried about siblings in the Israeli military and the threat of Hamas rocket strikes against civilian areas in Israel. Many of the group’s meetings during and after the war were tense, with voices raised and tears shed.


But because of careful facilitation by the groups’ leaders – who provided simultaneous translations in Hebrew and Arabic and encouraged students to focus on issues surrounding the war rather than blaming one another for its occurrence – the group held together. 


Just a couple of months after the war, the students were able to sit together again and laugh over a meal of hummus and falafel. As one student proudly reflected, eliciting nods from other participants, “If we were able to get through those times without hating each other, nothing can keep us from being friends.”


The recently-founded Journal of Inter-Religious Dialogue hopes to follow the ICCI’s example by facilitating dialogue about social, political and cultural issues affecting religious communities around the world, including those most challenging to discuss. By approaching contentious issues in an academic manner, it will provide a new means of engaging matters that often underlie inter-religious interaction but are seldom discussed. In so doing, we hope to provide a stronger basis for collaborative efforts and intellectual cross-pollination between religious communities.


The journal began to take shape in June 2008, when I approached Stephanie Hughes, Student Senate co-Chair at Union Theological Seminary, with an idea for a kind of inter-religious publication that goes a step beyond the present literature on inter-religious dialogue. As a rabbinical student, I felt motivated to find a partner from another religious background equally invested in the ideas of mutual respect, learning and collaboration.


Having formed a strong partnership, the two of us set off to found what became the Journal of Inter-Religious Dialogue. Neither of us held a PhD, but both of us felt compelled by our traditions to contribute to inter-religious work and study. In recognising our own limited experience in formal academic scholarship, we found a niche as facilitators who could both encourage and guide discussions.


While the first issue of the journal is dedicated to the dynamics of dialogue itself, subsequent issues will address topics that participants in inter-religious dialogue often shy away from. Thus the second issue (Fall 2009) will be entitled, “Engaging the Taboo: Gender, the Body, and Sexuality in our Religious Traditions,” and the third issue (Spring 2010) will focus on the role that religion can play in both fomenting and preventing violence.


The journal’s goal is to bring scholars together with activists and non-profit leaders to discuss these topics. By drawing members of all three groups together to learn, discuss and debate on a free online platform, we hope to promote innovative programming within the field. Moreover, because of its electronic format, the journal will be accessible to an international audience of seminarians, professors, and religious and civic leaders. Inter-religious dialogue, work and scholarship often take places locally, but lessons learnt can be applied globally. By engaging with some of the most difficult, yet important, topics in interfaith dialogue, we know these lessons will be worthwhile.



Joshua Stanton is co-founder and editor-in-chief of the Journal of Inter-Religious Dialogue (www.irdialogue.org) and a rabbinical student at Hebrew Union College. This article was adapted from the article written for the Common Ground News Service

One Response to “Taking Dialogue to the Next Level, By Joshua Stanton”

  1. Louise Vera says:

    As one who is a lay activist in interreligious dialogue for the last 30 years, I am so delighted to see that your goal is to bring scholars, lay activists and not-profit-leaders together! It’s difficult for those without Ph.D’s to be heard, although we activists have often done the work to set up for many a scholar. I look forward to this new format. Congratulations!
    Louise Barnes Vera
    Office for Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations
    Cincinnati, Ohio